Troubleshooting an STL file from Inventor R10
One of the things I do is design electronic packaging
for consumer products. Inventor R10 is my first
choice, although I will use SolidWorks, Pro/E, CADkey,
or MDT if I have to.
Recently, I designed a nice enclosure that consisted
of five parts. I perform a 'Save Copy As' stl file for all
of the parts and emailed them to the plastic
fabricator.
Four of the files could be read by his equipment, but
the fifth file was no good.
Here's how I tested it. I saved the file as an 'sat'
file. I opened it in MDT. I then performed an Export
to stl. When I selected the solid model, I got an
error that it did not lie on the proper XYZ octant.
What the heck does that mean? And of course, help
does not help. So, I emailed the subscription center
and a very nice guy informs me that it means that
the model lies below the 0,0,0 planes. This was true.
When I created the model in Inventor, I extruded mid-
plane into the positive/negative XY-plane direction.
So, I had two choices...I could go back to Inventor
and redefine my features on the planes, which would
involve basically re-building my part or I could go to
MDT, select the model, type MOVE, Select the center
of the model as the basepoint, 10,10,10.
No error message this time when I went to Export-
>stl. Emailed the file to the plastics house and they
gave the file a 'thumbs up'.
Lessons learned:
- Inventor needs to improve how they create stl
files...because most designers want to be able to
design for part maintainability, which means we
sometimes go into the negative planes.
- Being a subscription customer definitely pays
off.
- MDT is still a necessary tool to assist in
troubleshooting these types of problems.